Showing posts with label Brontë. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Brontë. Show all posts

Saturday, December 24, 2016

The Brilliant Brontës: Wide Sargasso Sea & The Brontë Cabinet

Anne Bronte (1820-1849), Emily Bronte (Thornton, 1818 - Haworth, 1848) and Charlotte Bronte (Thornton, 1816 - Haworth, 1855), English writers, Oil on canvas by Patrick Branwell Bronte (1817-1848), ca 1834. Photograph. Encyclopædia Britannica ImageQuest. Web. 19 Dec 2015.

I've read and re-read "Jane Eyre" of course, and I am sure that the character must be "built up"... The Creole in Charlotte Brontë's novel is a lay figure - repulsive which does not matter, and not once alive which does. She's necessary  to the plot, but always she shrieks, howls, laughs horribly attacks all and sundry - off stage. For me (and for you I hope) she must be right on stage. She must be at least plausible with a past, the reason why Mr. Rochester treats her so abominably and feels justified, the reason why he thinks she is mad and why of course she goes mad, even the reason why she tries to set everything on fire, and eventually succeeds.
~Jean Rhys, in a letter to Selma Vas Dias, April 9, 1958

Something else has become clear, too: the novel has forever changed the way we read Jane Eyre. As author Danielle McLaughlin recently put it, writing for The Paris Review: “The novel didn’t just take inspiration from Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre, it illuminated and confronted it, challenged the narrative”. Or, to quote novelist Michele Roberts, “Rhys took one of the works of genius of the 19th Century and turned it inside-out to create one of the works of genius of the 20th Century”.
~Hepzibah Anderson, "The book that changed Jane Eyre forever"

This year, in addition to celebrating the bicentenary of Charlotte Brontë, another related book has an anniversary - Wide Sargasso Sea, by Jean Rhys, was published in 1966. Wide Sargasso Sea tells the story of Bertha Mason, the "madwoman in the attic" of Charlotte's Jane Eyre. Though in three parts, it weighs in at a slight 112 pages in W.W. Norton & Company's 1999 edition - fulfilling the adage of quality over quantity.

Much of the narrative is told from Bertha's perspective, some from her unidentified husband's. The writing is poignant and evocative, sometimes reaching the pitch of a fever dream. Bertha was born Antoinette, her name changed by her husband because she shares it with her mother, who has been declared insane. Antoinette grows up on an estate in Jamaica, but she is not wealthy until her mother marries Mr. Mason - and, during her childhood, her Creole background is scorned with a particularly nasty epithet. The person who shows her the most kindness and understanding is the servant Christophine, but her influence, as a woman of color and a practitioner of voodoo, is viewed darkly by Antoinette's stepbrother and husband-to-be, among others. Young Antoinette's life is beset with mishaps and she seems prone to melancholy, but not necessarily madness.

Those who have read Jane Eyre will have some background knowledge of Bertha/Antoinette's story; Rhys here fleshes out the character, her atmospheric prose setting the scene firmly in the Caribbean milieu which Rhys, born in Dominica, hailed from, and bringing to life Charlotte Brontë's "poor ghost" and rather doing down any claims Mr. Rochester has to being a romantic hero. One of my favorite speeches of Antoinette's is when she is recounting her past to her husband and explains
'I was never sad in the morning...and every day was a fresh day for me. I remember the taste of milk and bread and the sound of the grandfather clocking ticking slowly and the first time I had my hair tied with string because there was no ribbon left and no money to buy any. All the flowers in the world were in our garden and sometimes when I was thirsty I licked raindrops from the Jasmine leaves after a shower. If I could make you see it, because they destroyed it and it is only here now.' She struck her forehead.

Most of the story takes place in the Caribbean, amidst the Sargasso Sea, which, as the "Backgrounds" section of this edition helpfully explains (courtesy of Rachel L. Carson), "...lies all about Bermuda and extends more than halfway across the Atlantic...with all its legendary terrors for sailing ships, [the sea] is a creation of the great currents of the North Atlantic that encircle it and bring into it the millions of tons of floating sargassum weed from which the place derives its name, and all the weird assemblage of animals that live in the weed." The "Backgrounds" section also helpfully includes excerpts from Jane Eyre that feature Bertha, selected letters of Jean Rhys, and more of interest for the scholar.

Jean Rhys was a protégée of Ford Madox Ford and wrote several other books, but Wide Sargasso Sea, written towards the end of her life, was considered her masterwork, and is still widely taught today.  Bertha/Antoinette seems to speak for all the women written out of history when she says, "Then I turned round and saw the sky. It was red and all my life was in it."


The other Brontë book I read to wrap up our Brontë challenge this month was The Brontë Cabinet: Three Lives in Nine Objects. The "objects" discussed are items such as letters, what we would call lap desks, memento mori jewelry, and pets, with each item getting about 30 pages of discussion. I had worried it might be a dry and academic tome, but in fact each chapter has proved to be a lively discussion of not just the object in question and its use by the Brontës, but also the history of the era, local folklore, and more - the chapter called "The Alchemy of Desks" veers into Charlotte and Emily's difficult adult relationship, and also into a discussion of Emily's pen use (apparently she found them "troublesome").

Some of the most fascinating tidbits I discovered from The Brontë Cabinet included the fact that, in that time period, "the receiver, rather than the sender, paid the postage to the letter carrier who came to the house door"  and "[m]ost personal  letters of the early nineteenth century...consisted of one page folded and sealed so that the address could be written directly on the letter." Correspondents often "cross-wrote" - "...instead of using a second page to continue a letter, turned the first sheet horizontally, and wrote over ("crossed") the original text at a right angle." The penny post (stamps!) came into use in 1840. Later, in "Death Made Material," there are some interesting anecdotes about "grave goods" - "belongings included with the corpse in case they might be needed on the other side" - including a story of Dante Gabriel Rossetti interring unpublished poetry in his wife's coffin, and then regretting his decision, and an unnamed Victorian who, forgetting to put her friend's son's letters in her friend's grave, instead put them in the grave of a mailman who died soon afterward - so the mailman could deliver them to her friend in the afterlife.

Both these books have been great reads! This ends our Brontë challenge for the year - thanks for taking an interest.


Tuesday, November 22, 2016

The Brilliant Brontës: Juvenilia


Anne Bronte (1820-1849), Emily Bronte (Thornton, 1818 - Haworth, 1848) and Charlotte Bronte (Thornton, 1816 - Haworth, 1855), English writers, Oil on canvas by Patrick Branwell Bronte (1817-1848), ca 1834. Photograph. Encyclopædia Britannica ImageQuest. Web. 19 Dec 2015.


We have one collection of  Brontë juvenilia in the library catalog: Tales of Glass Town, Angria, and Gondal: Selected Writings. Why should you read the early writings of the Brontës?  "The writings of Glass Town, Angria, and Gondal are youthful experiments in imitation and parody, wild romance and realistic recording; they demonstrate the playful literary world that provided a 'myth kitty' for their early - and later - work," the book's blurb proclaims. We had already heard a little about these early writings in recent stories about discovered manuscripts. When we read Worlds of Ink and Shadow for this challenge during the summer, one of the most interesting aspects of that novelization was the recreation of the Brontë siblings writing together - in Lena Coakley's book, their collaboration had a fantastical bent, but the idea of them working together despite differing viewpoints and shifting alliances was nevertheless compelling.

It's quite the story - their father gave Branwell a set of toy soldiers for his twelfth birthday (Charlotte would have been thirteen, Emily eleven, and Anne nine), and each sibling claimed a soldier for their own "character". These soldiers were the beginning of the Glass Town stories, which evolved into Angria (primarily Charlotte and Branwell's domain) and splintered off into Gondal (a special project of Emily and Anne). Charlotte started out with a character based on the Duke of Wellington; Branwell chose Napoleon; their sisters favored naming their characters for the explorers Parry and Ross. These stories were inspired by those the children had been reading in Blackwood's Magazine, and colored by their readings of classics such as The Arabian Nights (possibly the reason the siblings referred to themselves as "Genii" in their stories?) and Romantic poetry.  

The book is split into sections, so you can read writings by each Brontë - there are 300 pages of Charlotte to only 72 of Branwell, and even less of the younger sisters' output. Though only the poetry about Gondal survives, scholars have ruled it especially important link in the creation of Wuthering Heights. Charlotte's section includes two full-fledged novelettes, Mina Laury and Caroline Vernon, which both show her increasingly mature authorial voice, while Branwell's features both prose and poetry. Stories of Glass Town and Angria are actually set in a wildly inaccurate imagining of Africa and are studded with wars and political maneuvering and a complicated social structure, while the Gondal narrative, what can be reconstructed, appears more confined (literally, as dungeons are much mentioned) and harsh, with its main characters being dour and severe, a Yorkshireman and a Scot.

Ultimately, the siblings grew apart. Branwell and Emily still composed their sagas as adults, while Anne and Charlotte moved away from the juvenilia that sparked their earliest literary creations. But the juvenilia collected in these selected writings remain a fascinating glimpse into collaboration and process, if you have the inclination to immerse yourself in their world. This edition also features a glossary of characters and places, copious explanatory notes, and Emily and Anne's six "diary papers", which reveal both life at Haworth and more about Gondal, including this touching passage from Anne on the occasion of Emily's twenty-third birthday: "We are now all separate and not like likely to meet again for many a weary week but we are none of us ill that I know of and are all doing something for our own livelihood except Emily [the only sibling still at home] who however is as busy as any of us and in reality earns her food and raiment as much as we do." Eight years later, both sisters and their brother Branwell would be dead, predeceasing Charlotte by only 6 years.


Links

Brontë juvenilia : The History of Angria  & Combining fantasy and fact - video [British Library]

Childhood Writings [University of Missouri] 

A Teenaged Charlotte Brontë's Tiny Little Romance [Slate]

The genesis of genius [Harvard Gazette]

Check out the Brontë Sisters' Early Science Fiction [Flavorwire] 

The Brontës invented imaginary realms, and created some of the first fan-fiction [io9]

Saturday, October 29, 2016

The Brilliant Brontes: Agnes Grey: Governing the Heart



 Anne Bronte (1820-1849), Emily Bronte (Thornton, 1818 - Haworth, 1848) and Charlotte Bronte (Thornton, 1816 - Haworth, 1855), English writers, Oil on canvas by Patrick Branwell Bronte (1817-1848), ca 1834. Photograph. Encyclopædia Britannica ImageQuest. Web. 19 Dec 2015.


"I am miserable when I allow myself to dwell on the necessity of spending my life as a governess." 
- Charlotte Bronte

Jean Paul-Sarte is known for his declaration: "Hell is other people." Charlotte Bronte would have gone further and said, "Hell is other people's children." Anne Bronte, the youngest of her literary family, persevered as a governess far longer than Charlotte did. Her novel Agnes Grey, published in 1847 chronicles the  fictitious trials of a mild-mannered governess. Anne's novel was overshadowed by her elder sister Charlotte's dramatic, Gothic novel Jane Eyre, but Anne's novel paints a realistic portrait of the drudgery, disrespect, and powerlessness of being a governess in Victorian times.

According to Kathryn Hughes author of The Victorian Governess, 25,000 women earned their living as governesses, during a period of English economic instability owing to the Napoleonic wars. Middle class families coped with the financial meltdown by having their daughters work as governesses. As daughters of a poor clergyman, the Bronte sisters sought out work as governesses and also dreamed of opening their own school at the Haworth parsonage.

The life of a governess was friendless and isolated. Governesses taught and raised children, but were not a member of the family and also a source of resentment among the servants who couldn't absorb governesses into their own domestic pecking order. Governesses could move on through suitable marriages, but families were so afraid of having their sons wanting to marry the governess, that they were urged to only hire the plainest possible governesses.

Governesses were only needed for a few years to care for and instruct her employer's children, so these women were constantly having to look for a new job. Salaries were so low, there was nothing left to save for health care or retirement, especially if governesses were working to support their own families back at home. The specter of poverty always loomed, so in 1841 the Governesses' Benevolent Institution was created to help them with pensions. In addition to the lack of a living wage, governesses were in the bind of being unable to discipline their charges and being undermined by the parents they worked for. In a letter Charlotte sent to a mutual friend, she wrote, "Anne is not to return - Mrs. Ingham is a placid, mild woman - but as for the children it was one struggle of life-wearing exertion to keep them in anything like decent order."

Agnes, the daughter of a destitute clergyman, desires to prove herself and help her family earn money, as a governess. Her first job is at Wellwood house to work for the Bloomfield family. Mrs. Bloomfield spoils her children while Mr. Bloomfield openly disapproves of Agnes's work. The children are out of control and Agnes is blamed for their antics. Tom, the oldest Bloomfield child, enjoys torturing small animals, especially birds. Children in the Victorian era were considered to be wild animals to be brought to heel. Agnes Grey is a shocking novel that makes corporal punishment look like a reasonable option, because the children Agnes governs are sadistic, soulless, little monsters. In less than a year, Agnes is fired, since Mrs. Bloomfield thinks that her precious children aren't making the academic progress she expects.

Agnes refuses to give up and finds a position with the wealthy Murray family. The two boys, John and Charles, are both sent to school, but Agnes is left with the girls Rosalie and Matilda. Mathilda is a foul-mouthed, compulsive liar and tomboy. Rosalie is a vapid, two-faced flirt. Both girls enjoy bullying Agnes and using her as a social prop.

Agnes begins to visit Nancy Brown, an old woman with poor eyesight who needs help reading the Bible; there Agnes meets the new parson, Mr. Edward Weston. The novel begins to take an uplifting spiritual and romantic turn.  Agnes is surprised during a walk by Mr. Weston, who picks some wild violets for her, which she saves in her Bible. Their friendship is noticed by Rosalie Murray, who has entered into society and enjoys torturing her own suitors through malicious flirtation. Mr. Weston becomes Rosalie's latest target, which causes Agnes great internal anguish, although Rosalie marries and becomes Lady Ashby. As a proper Victorian governess, Agnes is unable to profess her love for Mr. Weston openly, but takes comfort in the Sunday services he presides over.

Agnes receives a note from her married sister Mary, that their father is dying and begs Agnes to come home. Agnes arrives too late to see her father alive. After his funeral, Agnes opens a small school with her mother, leaving behind the Murrays and Mr. Weston.

Agnes receives a letter from Rosalie who is miserable in her marriage and asks Agnes to come for a visit. Agnes is shocked by Rosalie's transformation into a trapped, miserable married woman. Rosalie admits that she loathes Lord Ashby and her mother-in-law, and claims he only left London because he was jealous of all the gentlemen she was attracting. Agnes also hears that Mr. Weston has left the area, and she grieves, believing she will not be able to see him again. Rosalie is not even happy with her own newborn baby, since she considers only a boy and potential heir to be of any value. Rosalie's failures as a wife and mother trouble Agnes. In keeping with Agnes's spiritual inner light brought out by her family and friendships with Nancy Brown and Mr. Weston, advises Rosalie:

"The best way to enjoy yourself is to do what is right, and hate nobody. The end of Religion is not to
teach us how to die, but how to live; and the earlier you become wise and good, the more of happiness you secure. And now, Lady Ashby, I have one more piece of advice to offer you, which is that you will not make an enemy of your mother-in-law. Don't get into the way of holding her at arm's length, and regarding her with jealous distrust. I never saw her, but I have heard good as well as evil respecting her, and I imagine that, though cold and haughty in her general demeanour, and even exacting in her requirements, she has strong affections for those who can reach them; and, though so blindly attached to her son, she is not without good principles, or incapable of hearing reason; and if you would but conciliate her a little, and adopt a friendly, open mannerand even confide your grievances to her ... real grievances, such as you have a right to complain of ... it is my firm belief that she would, in time, become your faithful friend, and a comfort and support to you, instead of the incubus you describe her."

Agnes leaves Ashby Park and gratefully returns home to her mother and their humble school. The day after she arrives, she goes for a walk on the sea shore and encounters Mr. Weston, who had been looking for her since he moved to the nearby parsonage. A respectful courtship ensures and they marry and have three children together, a much happier ending than Anne Bronte enjoyed in her own short life.

Of all of the Bronte sisters, Anne showed the most resilience in seeking and maintaining employment outside of the family circle. Anne first worked for the Ingham family at Blake Hall, in Mirfield, which is located in West Yorkshire. The children she taught were consistently disobedient and enjoyed tormenting her, knowing that their parents would do nothing to stop them and insist on treating their governess with any respect or cooperation.

Anne's second job as a governess was to the children of the Reverend Edmund Robinson and his wife Lydia, at Thorp Green Hall, located in York, and she worked for them from 1840 to 1845. The house appeared as Horton Lodge in her novel Agnes Grey. Anne had four pupils: Lydia, aged 15, Elizabeth, aged 13, Mary, aged 12, and Edmund, aged 8. This time Anne succeed in her job and was treated well by her employers. The Robinson daughters became her lifelong friends. Anne accompanied the family to the vacations to the coastal town of Scarborough, where she ultimately chose to die during her final illness due to tuberculosis. 

Anne made the mistake of getting a job for her unstable brother Branwell, who worked as a tutor for the  Robinsons' son, Edmund. Branwell returned the favor by instigating a disastrous affair with the lady of the house, Lydia Robinson. Anne had resigned and returned to Haworth with a clean nose, before Branwell was fired for his shameless misconduct.

Agnes Grey is a bold novel in terms of accentuating class tensions and snobbery with employers aimed at Agnes and Agnes herself judging her employers and the children under her care even more harshly. Women were barred from most professions and being a governess was considered the most respectable and realistic option to pursue. The Bronte sisters can be forgiven for their frustrations and superiority complexes. The misery of being a governess was so pronounced with the Bronte sisters, that they couldn't persevere in this profession, and fortunately for the world, they turned to writing and turned their struggles into outstanding literature, although their employers probably never thought they would generate such shocking material.




Thursday, September 15, 2016

The Brilliant Brontës: Non-Fiction

Anne Bronte (1820-1849), Emily Bronte (Thornton, 1818 - Haworth, 1848) and Charlotte Bronte (Thornton, 1816 - Haworth, 1855), English writers, Oil on canvas by Patrick Branwell Bronte (1817-1848), ca 1834. Photograph. Encyclopædia Britannica ImageQuest. Web. 19 Dec 2015.

The Brontë family, despite the brevity of their lives, their limited output as writers, and their cramped, confined lifestyle, have inspired many books to be written about them, at least one running up to over 800 pages. In addition to books specifically about the siblings, the dedicated Brontë fan can also read about Emily's relationship with her dog Keeper in Shaggy Muses: The Dogs Who Inspired Virginia Woolf, Emily Dickinson, Edith Wharton, Elizabeth Barrett Browning, and Emily Brontë, a book which discusses the ways in which dogs can be "a constant support for...creative life;" about the sisters' decision to use pen names in Nom de Plume: A (Secret) History of Pseudonyms; enjoy a conversation between the author A. S. Byatt and psychoanalyst Ignês Sodré about Charlotte Brontë's Villette in Imagining Characters: Conversations About Women Writers - Jane Austen, Charlotte Brontë, George Eliot, Willa Cather, Iris Murdoch, and Toni Morrison, a lively discussion that touches on the lies we tell ourselves, enabling, fashion, the importance of needlework, and beyond; those looking for book recommendations can check out Daphne Merkin's essay "Moping on the Moors" in her collection The Fame Lunches: On Wounded Icons, Money, Sex, the Brontes, and the Importance of Handbags - both a rumination on the Brontës and on the books written about them; and, from the book The Heroine's Bookshelf: Life Lessons From Jane Austen to Laura Ingalls Wilder, be inspired by literary heroine Jane Eyre in an essay entitled "Steadfastness."

For those looking for meatier tomes, the library catalog has a decent sampling of full-on Brontë biographies, too! Elizabeth Gaskell's biography of Charlotte is purported to be the source of much of the traditional Brontë family mythos; Juliet Barker's family biography is the aforementioned 830-pager, and well worth the read; we also very much enjoyed Lucasta Miller's book. As devoted members of Team Anne, we are still waiting for a standalone biography of our favorite Brontë, but for the moment, her inclusion in family biographies will have to do.


Charlotte Brontë: A Fiery Heart by Claire Harman

Charlotte Brontë: A Passionate Life by Lyndall Gordon

The Brontë Cabinet: Three Lives in Nine Objects by Deborah Lutz

Reading the Brontë Body: Disease, Desire, and the Constraints of Culture by Beth Torgerson [eBook]

A Brontë Family Chronology by Edward Chitham [eBook]

The Brontë Myth by Lucasta Miller 

Brontë by Glyn Hughes 

The Brontës by Juliet Barker 

The Brontës: Branwell, Anne, Emily, Charlotte by Bettina L. Knapp 

A Chainless Soul: A Life of Emily Brontë by Katherine Frank 

The Life of Charlotte Brontë by Elizabeth Gaskell [eBook]
   

Tuesday, August 30, 2016

The Brilliant Brontës: Brontës for Kids & Teens

Anne Bronte (1820-1849), Emily Bronte (Thornton, 1818 - Haworth, 1848) and Charlotte Bronte (Thornton, 1816 - Haworth, 1855), English writers, Oil on canvas by Patrick Branwell Bronte (1817-1848), ca 1834. Photograph. Encyclopædia Britannica ImageQuest. Web. 19 Dec 2015.

You might be surprised to hear that there are Brontë-inspired books aimed at kids and teens. Not a huge amount, as you might imagine, since bleak moors and unrequited passion might be a slightly hard sell for the younger set, but there are a few available, and they are not all biographies of the sisters, though some of the fiction has a "based-on-a-true-story" slant.

We chose a young adult eBook, Worlds of Ink and Shadow by Lena Coakley, for our Brontë read this month., and we were not disappointed. From the very first page we were hooked! The story drops readers into the lives of  the Brontës themselves, albeit with a supernatural twist. This could have gone either way - sometimes real people presented fictionally feel stiff or one-dimensional - but Lena Coakley appears to have done her research, and, apart from perhaps slightly modern turn of phrase at times, she presents what could be an entertaining portrait of the Brontë siblings in their mid-to-late teens, including Branwell. They squabble, they are lectured by their father, they worry their Aunt, and they have a lot of angst about their childhood pact with a character called Old Tom, which allows them to slip between the real world and the imagined worlds of their writings.

This paranormal thread could have toppled a storyline that presents the Brontë family with warts-and-all realism - each sibling has a distinct and recognizable character, and even their somewhat claustrophobic existence in Haworth Parsonage is vividly drawn. But the fantastical element provides a glimpse of the fictional worlds of Glass Town and Gondal that draws the reader in, and drama to bring out the best and worst of the siblings and keep the reader spellbound.

We highly recommend Worlds of Ink and Shadow! Here are some other Brontë titles from the library catalog to introduce kids and teens to their world:

Fiction

Jane, The Fox & Me by Fanny Britt [graphic novel]

The House of Dead Maids by Clare B. Dunkle [J Fiction]

Always Emily: A Novel of Intrigue and Romance by Michaela MacColl [YA eBook]

Catherine by April Lindner [YA eBook] 
 

A Family Called Brontë by Paula Guzzetti

Thursday, July 28, 2016

The Brilliant Brontes: Shirley: An Industrial Strength Novel

Anne Bronte (1820-1849), Emily Bronte (Thornton, 1818 - Haworth, 1848) and Charlotte Bronte (Thornton, 1816 - Haworth, 1855), English writers, Oil on canvas by Patrick Branwell Bronte (1817-1848), ca 1834. Photograph. Encyclopædia Britannica ImageQuest. Web. 19 Dec 2015. 

Charlotte Bronte wrote Shirley (1849) during the harrowing illnesses and deaths of her siblings Branwell, Emily, and Anne. Shirley is an industrial strength feminist novel set in Yorkshire during the turbulent year of 1811. Bronte's second novel confronts class divisions during England's Industrial Revolution and the Napoleonic Wars. The Luddite revolts in 19th-century Yorkshire consisted of English textile workers and weavers who feared that stocking and spinning frames and power looms threatened their livelihoods. Destroying threshing machines was a tactic Luddite's utilized in order to bargain with their employers. Some more peaceful textile workers organized structured societies to meet technological progress with provisions for unemployment, paid sick leave, and foreign influences against English interests. 

Charlotte Bronte's novel views this turbulence through the perspective of her main character Caroline Helstone, the mild-mannered orphaned niece of a terminally cranky pastor. Caroline was based on Bronte's sister Anne and Caroline's friend, the female landowner Shirley Keeldar was Charlotte's imaginative concept of  what her sister Emily could have been if she had been "placed in good health and prosperity".

Caroline's love interest Robert Moore is a harsh mill owner known for his coldness towards his employees. Robert lays the majority of his employees off, because his mill is in debt due to his late father's inefficiency and mortgages. Robert's older brother Louis becomes a private tutor, leaving Robert alone to turn their family's business around with the aid of new machinery which enables him to lay off even more employees. Angry, impoverished mill workers destroy his machinery in retaliation.

Shirley Keeldar is an independently wealthy heiress who lives with her devoted governess Mrs. Pryor. Caroline and Shirley's friendship is cemented in their desire to live meaningfully and help their destitute neighbors, who deteriorate into alcoholism and violence. Shirley becomes motivated to extend financial help the poorest of the poor and discourage attacks on Robert. Caroline is dismayed to witness Robert and Shirley's burgeoning friendship, which could become an advantageous marriage for both of them. In befitting Victorian fashion, Caroline becomes dangerously sick and is cared for by Mrs. Pryor, who reveals that she is Caroline's mother, who had escaped Caroline's abusive father. With the support of her mother, lovesick Caroline begins to recovery.

Deeply sensitive to her limited prospects, Caroline fears old maidenhood. Bronte's depictions of Victorian Spinsterhood are maddening and bleak. Despite Shirley's wealth and independence, she must also answer to her extended family, who wants her to marry well, despite her growing love for Louis Moore, the family tutor. Shirley's motives for helping Robert are also misconstrued by Robert, who proposes to Shirley in order to secure his dwindling fortunes. Shirley rebuffs him so harshly that Robert realizes that in order to regain his own dignity, he must be receptive to the idea of relinquishing his beleaguered mill and start over again, possibly in Canada, since the political climate makes it impossible for his mill to establish trade with America.
Ultimately, Robert is shot by his own laid off workers and has to recover at a friend's house. Gradually, Caroline and Robert re-establish their fractured friendship. The novel neatly ends with the respective marriages of Caroline with Robert and Shirley with Louis. However, by Shirley marrying Louis, she has to submit to her husband in all matters, even her own property, since women in that era were not allowed to own property.
The plight of women striving for meaning in a patriarchal society is captured in Bronte's depictions of disrespect incurred by spinsters, the emotional claustrophobia of young women waiting for their lives to begin through marriage and motherhood, and the disqualification of love as a deciding factor in most matches. 

Shirley was not as well-received as Jane Eyre, due to the sheer volume of this tome and the overblown, treacly prose. However, Bronte doesn't spare the clergy some judicious barbs in Shirley for their ineffectual ministering of mill workers struggling to survive a ruthless, changing world that threatens leave them. Social justice and romance make for an incongruous reading experience, but Charlotte's love and appreciation for her sister Emily shines through the complex and forthright character of Shirley Keeldar.

For further reading on the Bronte's world, The Public Library recommends:
Napoleon On War edited by Bruno Colson; translated by Gregory Elliott
Reading the Bronte Body [eBook] Disease, Desire, and the Constraints of Culture by Beth Torgerson                                    

Thursday, June 23, 2016

The Brilliant Brontes: Branwell Bronte: The Lost Son

Anne Bronte (1820-1849), Emily Bronte (Thornton, 1818 - Haworth, 1848) and Charlotte Bronte (Thornton, 1816 - Haworth, 1855), English writers, Oil on canvas by Patrick Branwell Bronte (1817-1848), ca 1834. Photograph. Encyclopædia Britannica ImageQuest. Web. 19 Dec 2015.


Patrick Branwell Bronte, was the only son in the Bronte family, but he became a tragic disappointment to himself and his relatives. Branwell died at the age of 31 due to alcoholism, opium addiction, and tuberculosis. Branwell, as he was called by his family, was as talented as Charlotte, Emily, and Anne, but lacked focus to such an extent that if he were alive today, he'd likely be diagnosed with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.  Branwell was the first published poet of the family and also pursued painting and music with the encouragement of his father, Reverend Patrick Bronte.

The Bronte family was constantly pummeled with losses, tragedy, and economic hardships. Their effervescent mother Maria Branwell Bronte died of uterine cancer when the children were very small. Two older sisters, Maria and Elizabeth, died of tuberculosis, exacerbated by their time enrolled at the notorious Cowan Bridge School. Their devoted servant, Tabitha Aykroyd, and somber aunt, Elizabeth Branwell, cared for the children after her sister's death and were constant, unselfish caregivers. Aunt Elizabeth remembered her three nieces in her last will and testament, leaving each of them £900, which made it possible for them to pursue writing full-time, after many attempts to provide for their family as teachers and governesses. Branwell was not remembered in her will, because it was assumed that as a man, he would be the most capable of making a living.

The graveyard surrounded the Bronte family parsonage's house and garden, which meant that decaying bodies polluted the water supply, which is about as unsanitary and Gothic as it can get. The villagers suffered even more from epidemics of cholera, typhus, smallpox, and dysentery, because the sewage drained in their direction. The average age of death was 25 years old. After the daughter's experiences at Cowan Bridge School, the world must have seemed to be an ominous place, despite their father's guidance and their spiritual inner resources. Branwell didn't find comfort in religion and even professed atheism, although on the day he died, he had a quick change of heart.

The deaths of their mother and especially their sister Maria impacted the family tremendously; however, Branwell seems to have never recovered from these devastating losses. Branwell's father, the Reverend Patrick Bronte insisted on educating Branwell at home, but his motives for doing so have been a subject of speculation. It could have been a cost saving measure so that the sisters could be educated away from home or Patrick's concerns about Branwell's propensity for tantrums and overall high-strung emotional instability. Regardless, Branwell was spoiled, coddled, severely isolated and unable to cope with reality as an adult. Patrick taught his children literature, geography, history, mathematics, the classics, Latin, French and poetry. Nothing was off limits to his children from his library. His educational contributions and encouragement for walking and enjoying the inspiring Yorkshire moors influenced his brilliant children immeasurably.

As a curate, Patrick Bronte realized that he would be unable to provide his daughters with dowries needed at that time to secure advantageous marriages for them. Charlotte, Emily, and Anne were acutely aware of their need to provide for not only their family, but for themselves after their father and aunt passed on. The Bronte children were extraordinarily intelligent, imaginative, and prolific writers, even at a very young age. Their first major literary undertaking came in the form of toy soldiers Patrick gave to twelve-year-old Branwell, which he shared with his sisters.

Branwell named his toy soldier Bonaparte, Charlotte's soldier was the Duke of Wellington, Emily named her soldier Gravey, and Anne dubbed her soldier Waiting Boy. These toy soldiers became vehicles for the poems, plays, and stories of their fantasy worlds of The Glass Town, Verdopolis, Gondal and Angria. The children's sources of inspiration came from The Arabian Nights, Lord Byron, and the political developments they followed in the news. Branwell drew the maps of Angria. Each child developed their writing skills through this creative refuge, producing tiny books in order to preserve their need for secrecy.

In 1831, Charlotte was sent to the Roe Head School in order to prepare herself for gainful employment and started to withdraw from Branwell. Emily and Anne began their own collaboration about the fictitious Gaaldine, an island in the South Pacific. As he grew older, Branwell began to hang out with the other town boys at the local tavern. He constantly borrowed money, incurred debts and tried to be a musician and a painter. There are numerous stories about why Branwell failed to apply to the Royal Academy of Arts, the most famous one being that Branwell was too intimidated and afraid of failure, so he spent the week sight-seeing and drinking the money provided for this important trip.

Branwell was apprenticed to a portrait painter named William Robinson. Branwell's famous portrait of his sisters originally included him, but at some point Branwell decided to remove himself by painting over his own figure. Eventually, Branwell decided to give up trying to make a living as a portrait painter, despite his promising talent. Supposedly, William Robinson didn't teach his student how to properly mix his paints. Branwell's paintings do have unpolished, amateurish qualities that testify to his lack of discipline.

In 1839, Branwell tutored two boys in the Lake District, but was fired in 1840. Branwell then tried to work as a clerk for the railroad and wrote poetry that he got published in various literary papers. Branwell was fired by the railroad in 1842 over bookkeeping errors, but probably more for a mixture of incompetence and drunkenness than deliberate theft. The next year, Branwell tutored the oldest son in the Robinson family, where his sister Anne was established as the governess. In July of 1845 he was fired for having had an affair with the mother, Lydia Robinson. He returned to Haworth in disgrace and sank into a consuming depression that was exacerbated by his alcohol and opium abuse. After the death of Mrs. Robinson's husband, she refused to reunite with Branwell and periodically sent him hush money, which he used to feed his addiction.

Branwell's behavior at home deteriorated and his family took the brunt of his self-pity, tantrums, debts, and destructive acts, such as setting his own bed on fire. Patrick took it upon himself to share a bed with Branwell in order to keep him under some semblance of control, even as Branwell exhibited delirium tremens. He died on September 24, 1848 of a combination of the effects of his addiction, which also masked a walloping case of tuberculosis. Branwell summed up his life with the following words: “In all my past life I have done nothing either great or good.”

Branwell's difficult personality and downward spiral of addiction impacted his sisters' novels. Anne Bronte spent considerable time caring for Branwell at his lowest moments, so she did not romanticize difficult men the way Charlotte and Emily did in their novels. In The Tenant of Wildfell Hall the mistreated wife, Helen Graham, flees her alcoholic husband, Arthur Huntingdon, whose vicious behavior is impacting their son. Anne's depiction of Arthur Huntingdon's demise mirrored Branwell's death and shed a light on how alcoholism affects families.

The character Hindly Earnshaw in Emily Bronte's novel Wuthering Heights, is not only an alcoholic, but cruel, miserable, and loses Wuthering Heights through accruing unmanageabel debt. Near the end of Branwell's life, his debts were considerable and the possibility of jail was imminent, despite his shattered health.

In Charlotte Bronte's novel, Jane Eyre, John Reed, Jane's loathsome cousin becomes an alcoholic and out of control gambler who commits suicide in order to escape his astronomical gambling debt. The gin-loving servant Grace Poole's naps allow Bertha to escape and set a fire in Mr. Rochester's bedroom and to ultimately set the fire that destroys Thornfield.

Alcoholism and substance abuse was one of the dark sides of the Victorian Era. People could obtain cocaine, laudanum, arsenic, and various kinds of opiates at the local drug store. The temperance movement was on the rise. Ironically, Patrick was the president of his local temperance society and Branwell served as the secretary.  Branwell was a lonely young man who craved male friendship. Alcoholics and drug addicts had a solitary struggle of harrowing abstinence tinged with stigma. The Bronte family was deeply enmeshed and helpless to save Branwell, who died, probably without ever being informed of the publication of his sisters' books.

In the aftermath of Branwell's death, Charlotte wrote to her friend Ellen Nussey:

"He Died after 20 minutes struggle on Sunday Morning 24th Septbr . He was perfectly conscious till the last agony came on - His mind had undergone the peculiar change which frequently precedes death, two days previously - the calm of better feelings filled it - a return of natural affection marked his last moments - he is in God's hands now - and the all - powerful - is likewise the all - merciful - a deep conviction that he rests at last - rests well after his brief, erring, suffering, feverish life fills and quiets my mind now. The final separation - the spectacle of his pale corpse gave more acute, bitter pain than I could have imagined - Till the last hour comes we never know how much we can forgive, pity, regret a near relation - All his vices were and are nothing now - we remember only his woes." - See more of Charlotte's letters at: http://www.bl.uk/collection-items/five-letters-from-charlotte-bront-to-ellen-nussey-and-w-s-williams-1848-1854-mainly-concerned-with-the-death-of-her-siblings#sthash.NEgMF9bv.dpu

For further reading about Branwell and his family check out the following recommendations:

The Infernal World of Branwell Brontë

The Brontës : Branwell, Anne, Emily, Charlotte  

*This post is part of our year-long Brilliant Brontës challenge! To see more posts, search for the labels "Brontë, challenge" in the blog sidebar. 

Tuesday, May 17, 2016

The Brilliant Brontës: Brontë Fanfic

Anne Brontë (1820-1849), Emily Brontë (Thornton, 1818 - Haworth, 1848) and Charlotte Brontë (Thornton, 1816 - Haworth, 1855), English writers, Oil on canvas by Patrick Branwell Brontë (1817-1848), ca 1834. Photograph. Encyclopædia Britannica ImageQuest. Web. 19 Dec 2015.

Fanfiction is very popular these days - "If you love something, write a fanfic about it," an article from Entertainment Weekly enthused recently (actually about Beyoncé's new album). So, it's no surprise that there have been many stories inspired by the Brontës, online and in print. (Not quite as many novels as those inspired by Jane Austen, but a healthy amount.) Perhaps it doesn't hurt that there are so few books written by the Brontë sisters - one by Emily, two by Anne, and only three published by Charlotte in her lifetime (The Professor, written before Jane Eyre, was rejected by several publishing houses and only published posthumously) - and that many people (myself included) find their short lives endlessly fascinating, so there is a lot left to the imagination.

I read two books inspired by the Brontës for this post: The Brontë Project: A Novel of Passion, Desire, and Good PR by Jennifer Vandever and The Madwoman Upstairs by Catherine Lowell. Both are fictionalized accounts of Brontë studies in academia. In both books, the protagonists are in crisis, but for different reasons. In The Brontë Project, Sara Frost is a junior scholar at a New York University; in The Madwoman Upstairs, Samantha Whipple, who happens to be the last remaining descendant of the Brontës, has just matriculated at Oxford. Sara's story begins when Claire, a Princess Diana expert, comes to campus and sends Sara's life spinning out of control with one comment at a cocktail party. In Samantha's case, she's come to university following the death of her father, a famous writer and Brontë scholar whose  untimely death has caused her to turn her back on literature and her famous heritage. Instead of wholeheartedly pursuing her studies, she finds herself the subject of articles in the school newspaper which she describes as "verbal vomit"; entangled with her father's nemesis; and receiving mysterious copies of Brontë novels, annotated in her father's handwriting.

Both novels have a wry sense of humor. In The Brontë Project, we find that

[Sara's] parents, both therapists, tried to snap her out of it. "Now, how could Cathy and Heathcliff resolve this problem by communicating their feelings before it leads to a fatality? What about the ending disturbs you? How could you change that? Could Heathcliff have worn a warmer coat? How about Cathy paying more attention to her health?" 

In The Madwoman Upstairs, Samantha has a drily sarcastic voice when narrating her own foibles, tending to tongue-in-cheek descriptions: "We entered a vast, bottomless silence. I scrambled for better conversation topics. This would all have been far less stressful in the movie version of our lives. The long silences would have been edited out."

Both novels are unafraid to discuss literary history and theory. In The Madwoman Upstairs, during Samantha's sessions with her tutor (and remembered discussions with her father), many theories are tossed into the mix, from how to discuss literature (authorial intent versus textual analysis) to the possibility that Catherine and Heathcliff are actually half-siblings to accusations that Charlotte Brontë stole Anne's story when she wrote Jane Eyre. The Brontë Project has its own theories, including one that connects the sisters to Princess Diana:

"Obviously, emotional states, even telepathy, were elevated to a place of prime significance in the works of all the Brontës," she said. "There is a kind of psychological intensity that was particularly disturbing and exciting to audiences of that time and today as well, I think. What's more, even though their works were dismissed as 'unladylike', they did focus a lot of literary attention on those aspects that have been stereotypically associated with the feminine - intuition, emotions, affairs of the heart - and made them central, and, in fact, the elements that defined a life more acutely than the day-to-day reality that existed on the surface... Likewise, I think Diana called a lot of attention to these same things - in today's parlance, self-esteem, bulimia, whatever. She was really continuing the tradition that the Brontës pioneered of accepting and using her emotional life as the point of engagement with the rest of the world."

Despite discussions of literary theory, both books are entertaining reads, though I preferred the more lively The Madwoman UpstairsThe Brontë Project lost the plot a bit in Part Two, though I did enjoy the way it employed quotes by Charlotte Brontë as chapter headings, perhaps to help readers to see the connections between "the mythology of romance [and] the reality of modern love," as the book blurb claims.

Would you like to try some Brontë fanfic for yourself? We've compiled a list of some other fictions inspired by the Brontës in the library catalog, whether you'd prefer to read fanfic based on their lives, their works, or beyond.

Lives of the Brontës

Becoming Jane Eyre by Sheila Kohler 

Emily's Ghost: A Novel of the Brontë Sisters by Denise Giardina 

The Secret Adventures of Charlotte Brontë by Laura Joh Rowland 

Romancing Miss Brontë by Juliet Gael  [eAudioBook]

The Secret Diaries of Charlotte Brontë by Syrie James [eBook]
 
Based on the Books

Wide Sargasso Sea by Jean Rhys 

The Lost Child by Caryl Phillips 

Jane Slayre: The Literary Classic - With a Blood-Sucking Twist by Charlotte Brontë and Sherri Browning Erwin [eAudioBook] 

Jane Eyrotica by Charlotte Brontë and Karena Rose 

Emma Brown by Clare Boyland and Charlotte Brontë 

Sequels

Mrs Rochester by Hilary Bailey [eBook]

Jane Eyre's Daughter by Elizabeth Newark [eBook] 


 Miscellaneous 

The Eyre Affair by Jasper Fforde 

*This post is part of our year-long Brilliant Brontës challenge! To see more posts, search for the labels "Brontë, challenge" in the blog sidebar.